Research note · Chapter I
It had been a friend
Most readers meet Miss Taylor as the woman who “had been a friend and companion such as few possessed.” She had been. But that’s not what the first edition printed. In 1815 the sentence reads: It had been a friend and companion. The Project Gutenberg text, which is how most people read Emma online, makes her She.
One word, and a different sentence. The 1815 version holds Miss Taylor at a distance, as a thing that Emma had and has now lost. The later version is warmer and simpler, and it isn’t what was printed.
Chapter I contains 91 other differences. Some are spelling (every body, to-day, shew, foretel). Most are punctuation: thirty-odd commas that weren’t in the first edition, and ten that were but have been taken out. Austen’s 1815 prose runs with far fewer pauses than the version most people read.


